Game Review: Ghostwire Tokyo


Ghostwire: Tokyo is a first-person, open-world, action-adventure video game developed by Tango Gameworks and published by Bethesda Softworks.  Development on Ghostwire: Tokyo was led initially by Ikumi Nakamura who took up the role of creative director after previously working as an art designer for the studio.  Despite her clear ambition and vison, it was announced Nakamura left Tango Gameworks in late 2019 and Kenji Kimura stepped in to fill the creative director role soon after. While the studio wanted to ensure the game had the horror elements their fans had come to expect, Tango Gameworks wanted to make this game primarily action-driven as well, so they hired Shinichirō Hara with his experience working on Doom (2016) to help formulate the primary gameplay experience. The title released originally as a PlayStation 5 exclusive in March 2022, but after being acquired by Xbox Game Studios, the title soon released the following year on Xbox Series X/S units following the expiry of the exclusive agreement contract. Reception for the title was fairly respectable; aggregating a critical average on 77 on OpenCritic although I can’t attest for the commercial success as Bethesda never publicly announced sales figure since the title’s release.

The narrative of Ghostwire: Tokyo follows primary protagonist Akito Izuki, a young adult who gets caught up in a bizarre world of demons and spirits when he is partially possessed by a spirit called KK.  KK explains to Akito that Tokyo has been trapped in an endless fog which has turned all of the local residents into spirits, with only Akito surviving thanks to KK’s partial possession.  It soon becomes apparent that the culprit behind the vanishing of Tokyo’s residents is a mysterious man wearing a Hannya mask. Broadcasting himself all across Tokyo, the man makes clear his intent to use the spirits he harnesses with the help of his demonic underlings to break down the barrier between life and death.  Akito’s stake in the fight isn’t just about survival either, as the masked man takes great interest in his comatose sister and kidnaps her with intent to use her in his final ritual. Akito and KK must learn to work together as the pair travel across Shibuya as they aim to put a stop to the masked man’s nefarious scheme and rescue the residents of Tokyo from being lost as spirits permanently.

The narrative while definitely original, struggles to offer much to engage to with the way it’s structured and paced. Due to the fact the entire city has been essentially blipped, there’s a very limited range of physical characters who inhabit the story besides Akito and the masked man.  The story relies heavily on the dysfunctional relationship between Akito and his spiritual companion KK to do much of the heavy lifting and it becomes clear that it can only so much to make up for the general lack of content behind the narrative structure. There’s just very little going on narratively that it feels like there’s a lot of padding and lull periods that prolong what is essentially a shallow idea with little definition to it. I think the final two chapters of the story do have a strong emotional foundation to acknowledge, but they don’t feel all that well-earned as the game doesn’t lead itself to these moments in any kind of cohesive fashion.

The gameplay portion of the game is the most egregious example for me however, because there’s both stuff to love and hate here. The map design of Shibuya is vast and because of that, Tango Gameworks worked to populate the world with a plethora of content to help justify your time within it. Sadly though, this content falls into all the very common trappings of open world ‘busywork’ mechanics that I truly hate. The best open world games make the world and gameplay work in synchronisation with one another and its clear Ghostwire: Tokyo’s world was designed firstly and then injected with a plethora of half-hearted content to give it definition after.  The end result of this design philosophy is a truly nauseating level of content to sift through that makes the prospect of progressing through the world less appealing. There’s just so much tedious content here that becomes repetitive insanely quickly when you consider the collectables to obtain, spirits to save, Yokai to dispel and torri gates to cleanse.  The only saving grace for me was the side missions as I did find they offered a varying quality of interesting, bite-sized concepts to play around in, though it’s important to note that the quality of each definitely ranged. 

Your primary means of interacting with the game is through its combat and while I appreciate the scope of this system, that too ends up falling to the games repetitive nature. Ethereal Weaving allows Akito to tune himself into the magical qualities of the spirit world and produce it into a form of energy that can be cast as his enemies. These energies take three elemental forms; wind, water and fire. Wind serves as your primary attack, dealing regular targeted damage.  Water works as an area of effect attack which allows you to cast energy in a wide arch to hit multiple enemies at once.  Fire serves as the strongest attack as it deals massive damage to all enemies in the vicinity of its deployment.  Casting these attacks can be fun and there’s a fair level of depth to their power curve through the skill system as well. The issue however is that your application of these attacks will get really old, really quick, as you dispatch enemies over and over again. I can at least appreciate Tango Gameworks incorporated a varied range of enemy designs to challenge you throughout the course of the game as you grow stronger, but its appeal is hampered by how limited the combat system feels by comparison.

Where Ghostwire: Tokyo  definitely succeeds is in the visual side of things.  The effort to faithfully represent the Shibuya district of Tokyo hasn’t gone unnoticed here as I honestly feel the environmental design is the games strongest showcase. There’s just so much density and detail in the world design as you genuinely feel you’re walking the abandoned streets of Shibuya and feeling all aspects of the culture projected on your screen.  The fact that there’s a notable variation in districts in the city helps to reinforce the density of the map too. One minute you’ll be wandering the narrow, neon-lit alleys filled to the brim with gambling dens and arcade venues; and the next minute you’ll be in the quieter suburban district where you see compact town-houses and apartments.  There’s just so much to marvel at within the world of Ghostwire: Tokyo and Tango Gameworks did a phenomenal job realising the visual core of the game’s world.  I also want to give praise to the enemy and NPC designs of the game, as Tango Gameworks clearly went out of their way to realize these character models in all of the traditional horrific ways their original folklore implies. 

Ghostwire: Tokyo is a good game on the surface level but the longer you play and the deeper you dive into its mechanics, you soon realize how hollow the actual experience is.  You can’t fault the game for trying to be original in its intent and there’s enough here to at least warrant giving the game a try if you’re a fan of Tango Gameworks’ prior works or Japanese-inspired games in general.  I think for me though Ghostwire: Tokyo just gets too many things wrong on so many fundamental levels that I can’t pretend I’m sad to be done with it; which is never typically a good emotional response to have when beating a video game for the first time.

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐

Comments

Popular Posts